Bet, derivative or crypto-asset? Europe’s prediction market problem

The question regulators are now asking

European regulators have stopped asking whether prediction markets are popular and started asking what they legally are. Since June, nine gambling authorities have launched a joint initiative against unlicensed operators, and on 3 July ESMA stated that some event contracts are binary options that cannot be marketed or sold to retail clients at all.

The same product can be a bet, a derivative or a crypto-asset, depending on how it is built. That classification question runs through every iGaming, esports and skill-gaming mandate we advise on. It is also the question at the centre of a recent opinion we prepared for a skill-based esports platform. This article sets out where the law now stands and what this exercise teaches.

What changed between June and November

Three moves in five months have narrowed the room for arguing that a prediction product is none of the above. An event contract can now fall into one of three regimes, and each has a different regulator and a different consequence.

ClassificationWhen it appliesConsequence
MiFID II financial instrument (binary option)All-or-nothing contract on an underlying listed in Annex I, Section C(4) to (10)Retail marketing, distribution and sale prohibited; MiFID authorisation needed for any client category
MiCA crypto-assetContract is not a financial instrument but is issued or settled in token formCrypto-asset service provider authorisation, unless exempt
Gambling betStake on an uncertain outcome, paid out if the bettor is rightNational gambling licence; blocking, fines, advertising limits

18 June: nine regulators coordinate. Authorities from Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Spain and Switzerland announced a joint initiative against operators offering prediction products without a local licence, treating them as gambling that requires local authorisation. Spain’s DGOJ had already blocked Polymarket and Kalshi in May, and France and the Netherlands use geoblocking. Malta did not join. Ireland’s regulator has said these products bear “the hallmarks of betting activity”.

3 July: ESMA closes the “it is not a binary option” argument. In its public statement on event contracts (ESMA35-243228190-8148), ESMA says the product’s name is not decisive and firms must carry out a careful legal analysis of how it works. A “coupon” or “reward” does not change a contract’s binary nature, and distribution to non-retail clients still requires MiFID authorisation. The statement creates no new law: national binary options measures have applied in all 27 Member States since 1 July 2019. ESMA also notes that an event contract may be a bet under national gambling law, and does not resolve that overlap.

What remains open. The boundary depends on whether the Annex I list is exhaustive or illustrative. Outcomes in politics, sport and entertainment fall outside the clearly listed categories, so their treatment turns on the product’s structure and context. Gibraltar has taken a third route, a dedicated regime that treats prediction markets as a separate authorised activity. Italy’s Prediction Markets Summit on 9 and 10 November includes a panel on whether financial or gaming regulators should supervise them.

The same fault line in the US. New York sued Kalshi in July, alleging an unlicensed gambling business. Kalshi answers that its contracts are federally regulated.

Payments follow the product. An iGB Intelligence report published on 3 November puts stablecoins at about 75% of crypto casino deposits and notes that MiCA’s transitional period ended in July.  Regulators will ask who holds the funds and under which registration settlement occurs.

What happens when igaming tournaments pay in cash or crypto prizes?

We had recently advised a Cyprus-based skill esports platform. The game’s was structured as follows: players enter paid tournaments, are matched by skill level, and win cash or crypto prizes; revenue comes from entry fees and commissions on winnings. We were asked whether the model is lawful in Cyprus and whether it counts as gambling or as a securities trading platform in its main markets. The opinion pre-dates ESMA’s statement, but it applies the method ESMA now expects: classify by function, and test each regime separately.

  • Gambling. The Cyprus Betting Law (37(I)/2019) defines a bet by reference to winnings fixed by the organiser from the stake and specified odds, on sporting events or events involving natural persons. A tournament decided by player performance is not a bet, and publishing or operating video games needs no licence. Elsewhere, gambling tests generally ask for a stake, an outcome determined predominantly by chance, and a prize. Skill predominance takes a product outside them, but cash prizes are where scrutiny concentrates.
  • Payments. PSD2 applies if the platform intermediates payments between players or lets rewards be redeemed for fiat through it. Withdrawals went only to the user’s own verified account or wallet, so there was no payer-to-payee intermediation. Crypto payouts sit outside PSD2, and conversion at withdrawal is an exchange function.
  • MiFID II. Mainstream cryptocurrencies are not financial instruments unless structured to confer securities-like rights, and converting crypto to fiat at withdrawal is not an investment service.
  • AML. Even where a gaming operator is not an obliged entity, expectations of transparency and suspicion reporting arise where tokens carry monetary value, player-to-player transfers resemble remittance, or there is cash-out or crypto integration.

The same grid applies to prediction markets, with one difference. In skill gaming, the risk sits in how rewards are structured. In a prediction market the product is itself a payout on a future event, so the gambling and MiFID overlap cannot be designed away. On its face, the Cyprus bet definition (organiser-fixed winnings, sporting or human events) does not map neatly onto an election or economic-statistic contract, which pushes the analysis towards CySEC and MiCA. That is our reading, and it is untested. It also does not make such a product safe: the National Betting Authority reported 22,009 sites on its blocklist at the end of 2025.

Labels cut both ways. In June, Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court ruled that so-called skill games are slot machines under state law. A product’s name, whether “market” or “skill”, does not decide its classification.

Practical takeaways

  1. Document the classification. ESMA expects a careful legal analysis of how the product works. A written opinion on the gambling, MiFID, MiCA and payments questions is now part of the compliance file, not an optional extra.
  2. Test each product in each market. Nine regulators already treat prediction products as gambling, while ESMA treats some as binary options. One licence or one conclusion does not carry across borders.
  3. Do not rely on a favourable licence elsewhere. A Gibraltar authorisation does not give access to markets whose regulators require local authorisation.
  4. Design the money flow deliberately. Payouts to the user’s own verified account or wallet, no player-to-player transfers and no redemption through the platform keep a skill product out of payment services. Settlement in stablecoins raises the question of who holds the funds.
  5. Keep gambling features out of skill products, or license them. Paid entry with cash prizes is the point at which a skill claim is tested hardest.
  6. Expect enforcement to be cross-border. Blocking, geoblocking and warnings to sponsors are the tools already in use.

For more information or legal advice on igaming structures with prediction markets and payments in the form of cash or crypto, feel free to drop us an email at contact@solsiduslaw.com

Sign-up today!

Get up-to-date information, directly to your inbox.